In 2019, the National Dental Examining Board of Canada (NDEB), as part of its five-year strategic plan, committed to undertake an evaluation of the existing Equivalency Process for graduates of non-accredited dental programs. This review was intended to identify strengths and potential areas for modifications in the evaluation of international dental graduates who are seeking licensure in Canada.
The NDEB previously examined the blueprint for the Equivalency Process in 2016 after completing a national study to identify and measure the knowledge, skills, and abilities (KSAs) required for entry to dental practice in Canada. Using the results of this analysis, NDEB examiners reviewed the blueprints for each of the examinations in the Equivalency Process; the Assessment of Fundamental Knowledge (AFK), the Assessment of Clinical Skills (ACS), and the Assessment of Clinical Judgment (ACJ) and recommended a series of changes the Board.
Over the last year, the NDEB has considered these recommendations, the 2019 evaluation for the Equivalency Process, and consulted with many of its stakeholders. The result is a multi-stage plan to modify the Equivalency Process while preserving the fairness, validity and reliability of its examinations.
The first step relates to the total number of questions on the AFK. The AFK is currently a 300 question multiple-choice examination. After thorough investigation, independent psychometric consultants have recommended that the number of questions on the examination could be reduced while still maintaining strong validity and reliability. Therefore, beginning in 2021 the AFK will be comprised of 200 questions. The examination will continue to be administered electronically.
The second step is an update to eligibility for the examinations in the Equivalency Process. Currently, examinees who are successful in the AFK are then eligible to take both the ACJ and the ACS at the same time or in the order of their choosing. Beginning in 2022, the eligibility will become sequential. Participants who successfully complete the AFK will first be eligible to take the ACJ. Once successful in the ACJ, examinees will be eligible to sit the ACS. This change is being made to align the testing with the principle that individuals must demonstrate that they have clinical judgement prior to performing technical skills on patients, especially irreversible dental procedures.
The third step involves the ACS. Currently, the ACS can be taken a maximum of three times. Examinees can fail one of 12 requirements and still pass the examination. In the updated Equivalency Process model, an examinee will be able to take the new ACS an unlimited number of times. However, they will not be permitted to fail any requirements. This is a significant change from the existing structure. The new ACS will introduce new requirements that will test skills required for general practitioner dentists. The NDEB expects this new ACS to be in place in 2022.
The NDEB will spend the coming months updating its By-laws and developing the processes for applying the new eligibility criteria.
Finally, the NDEB is excited to announce that it is beginning the construction of an in-house ACS testing facility in Ottawa, Ontario. The development of the NDEB ACS facility will have many benefits. Primarily it will allow the NDEB to administer the new ACS in a controlled purpose-built testing environment on a regular basis throughout the year, reducing scheduling bottlenecks while increasing capacity for this examination. For examinees, it provides greater scheduling flexibility, a consistent testing experience, and an overall lower stress environment. The NDEB is projecting to open the facility in time to offer the new ACS in 2022.
The NDEB has garnered significant support for the Equivalency Process changes from its stakeholders and is confident these changes will continue its ability to conduct fair, valid, and reliable assessments of competence for beginning dental practitioners in Canada.
The NDEB is currently developing the By-laws for the implementation of the revised Equivalency Process. Many questions about eligibility, repeats, and requalification will be answered when those By-laws are finalized and adopted by the Board in May 2021. In the meantime, you can find some Qs and As about the revised Equivalency Process below.
Frequently Asked Questions
How will I know if I will be eligible to take the modified ACS?
Eligibility for the ACS will require that you have successfully completed the AFK and ACJ.
If you had previously become ineligible for the Equivalency Process due to failure of the ACS three times, as of January 2022 you will have the ability to restart the Equivalency Process. Details about this process will be available in the fall.
What if I am ineligible because I failed the AFK or ACJ three times, will I be able to restart the process in 2022?
Only those who are ineligible because of three ACS failures will be able to restart the Equivalency Process in 2022.
What if I already passed the ACS but have not passed the ACJ?
If an individual has already passed the ACS but not the ACJ when the eligibility requirements change in January 2022, they will only be required to complete the ACJ. They will not be required to retake the ACS.
Will the reduction of questions in the AFK change the blueprint or timing for the examination?
With the reduction of questions, the time for the AFK will also be reduced. This information will be in the updated AFK protocol available in the spring. The AFK blueprint will not change.
Will any of the other examinations in the Equivalency Process go to unlimited attempts?
Only the ACS will move to unlimited attempts. Individuals will be able to take the ACS an unlimited number of attempts in a 60 month period. If they are unsuccessful, they will need to requalify for the ACS by repeating the AFK and ACJ. This is in place to ensure currency of knowledge and judgement.
Is there a limit on how many times a person can restart the Equivalency Process?
A person can go through the Equivalency Process in the new system a maximum of two times. If they are unsuccessful, they will need to complete a Degree Completion Program or DDS/DMD/BDS program in order to qualify for the Certification examinations.
Will the existing ACS and modified ACS run in parallel?
When the modified ACS is launched the existing ACS will no longer be offered.
When will we know what will be tested on the modified ACS?
The modified ACS blueprint is currently in development. The blueprint will be approved by the Board at the Annual Meeting in October 2021 and then made available to examinees.
How often will the ACS run in the new NDEB test facility?
The development of an in-house testing facility for the ACS will allow the examination to be run regularly throughout the year. The facility will be designed to test smaller groups of examinees more frequently. This has many advantages for both the examinees and the NDEB including a lower stress environment, increased access to the exam, flexible test dates, and more.